A Sandwich Made With Apples Soaked In Maple Syrup

I just learned about the most lovely sandwich made with apples soaked in maple syrup.


In her memoir The Mud Season, author Ellen Stimson shares her family’s experience selling their St. Louis, MO business and moving to a small town in Vermont because it was pretty. They buy an old country general store and have misadvanture after misadventure with livestock, weather, and quarrels with local residents. In one chapter, Stimson discusses how her banker had to inform her people had stopped shopping at her store because she moved the bread to a different shelf, and, in another, the challenges of adopting orphaned lambs.

Although I can’t relate to running a rural general store in Vermont, I can relate to Stimson trying to fit into a new community. I love this piece of advice a neighbor gave her:

File_000 (6)

What captivated my attention the most was her description of a toasted sandwich layered with meat, Vermont cheddar, and maple syrup-soaked apple slices. The book is back at the library now and I can’t quite recall her exact recipe. I do remember Stimson recommending that one should try to soak the apple slices in maple syrup for at least two hours and describing how Vermonters prefer Grade B maple syrup because it has more flavor. I never find grade B maple syrup at the stores, but would love to try some.

This sandwich is so wonderful because of all of the contrasting flavors and textures; the mapley sweetness and crunch of the apples, melted cheddar, and salty ham. It’s like the best grilled ham and cheese sandwich.

Here’s how I recreated it at home:


Sharp white cheddar
Apples soaked in maple syrup


  1. In a small container, soak thin slices of apple in maple syrup.
  2. To assemble the sandwich, layer sliced ham, apples, and sharp white cheddar.
  3. Toast sandwich in butter until the cheese melts and the bread turns golden brown.
  4. Slice and serve.


  1. Beth Ann Chiles

    This looks amazing. I totally need to make it and also check out that book. 🙂

    • Jeni

      It will make you NEVER want to sell everything and buy a General Store in a tiny town in Vermont.

  2. Katy F.

    I’m going to try this for lunch this weekend!!

  3. Haley @ Cheap Recipe Blog

    Jeni – this is so cool! That sounds absolutely delicious. I was just in Vermont in September and bought a bunch of maple syrup. I have some grade B in the kitchen – woohoo!

  4. Wendy

    No worries! Trader Joe’s has all of the Grade B you could want. I use it in baking all the time. Maple soaked apples on a turkey sandwich is perfect for left over Thanksgiving turkey! I am going to make sure we have plenty of leftovers.

    • Jeni

      Thanks Wendy. We totally missed the Grade B last time. We’ll have to do this with our leftover turkey too. Thanks for the tip.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

© 2024 Jeni Eats

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑

Visit Us
Follow Me