In my latest subscription box adventure, this Korean tries a Korean beauty product box.
I’ve seen reviews of sample boxes from Memebox, a company that sells Korean beauty products and curates sample boxes. South Korean culture is beauty-focused and produces many products we don’t often find in America. From what I gather from other bloggers’ Memebox reviews, Korean products are not only unique, but packaged in quirky ways. For example, this loose powder that comes in an orb with a bow, cupcake lifting cream, and all of these strange masks.
Memebox differs from ipsy or Birchbox in that you choose the boxes you want to order and they come in different sizes and price ranges. I chose the Makeup Edition Memebox which cost $23 + $7 shipping and was supposed to contain four to eight full-size and sample-size products. I hoped that choosing a makeup-focused box would provide me with the opportunity to try cosmetics in colors that would compliment my Asian complexion.
Subscribers can earn earn points (1 point = $1). For example, I earned seven points by sending an email to their customer service providing the name of a blog offering a referral discount and by creating an account on their website. Seven dollars covered the shipping charge so my box cost $23. You can also earn points by purchasing certain products.
I did not upgrade to express shipping so my box shipped on the 16th and arrived in my mailbox on the 23rd.
It was not what I expected or hoped for. Here’s what I found inside:
This box contained five full-sized products along with a sheet describing each one and listing their prices. Let’s start with my least favorite product, first.
I wasn’t thrilled to find a makeup base. This is not a product I’ve ever used or have a desire to use. I feel like I put enough layers on my face with a moisturizer, sunscreen, foundation and powder.
This base is tinted green which is supposed to reduce redness which could be helpful for various skin conditions or scars.
Plus, what’s up with this lady on the package?
I was as equally unexcited to find this anti pore eraser balm for similar reasons. It’s supposed to help minimize the appearance of pores and control sebum.
I tried a little bit on my hand. The balm is very light and blends into the skin easily. It really does seem to fill in skin texturing and creates a perfectly smooth surface which is cool and kind of freaks me out. There’s nothing wrong with this balm, it’s just not something I care to use. Maybe I’m weird, but I’m kind of okay being porey and a little shiny.
As if green makeup base and pore reducing balm didn’t make this box blemish-focused enough, I got a concealer pencil.
The color matches my skin well so I tried it on a couple pimples. It really didn’t make enough of a visible a difference that I would consider purchasing it for $18.
This blush is slightly less boring than the blemish concealers. It’s a light peach/orange color and I’ll have to try it later because I don’t even own a blush brush.
I couldn’t help but compare this box to being a kid and receiving socks from my parents at Christmas. Sure, they are practical, but not very much fun.
This tint gloss is my favorite product in the box. At first, I was alarmed by its flourescent orange color. Fortunately, the color looks more subtle when I apply it to my lips.
It’s still an unusual color, but I like it. The gloss feels light and smooth without being sticky. And the applicator’s sponge shape is, um, interesting. . .
I’m not going to sugar coat this; I’m disappointed in my first Memebox. I ordered it over a month ago because they sell out quickly and have been waiting in anticipation for fun Korean makeup samples. Although all five items are full-sized, I did not want three blemish concealing products. I had hoped for colorful cosmetics like eyeshadows, mascara, nail polish, lipsticks, and really, anything else!
For my wants and needs, this is a terrible curation of products with little variety. I don’t care if the actual value of the products exceeds the $23 I paid for the box. They aren’t items I wanted or will use, so I essentially paid $23 for a lip gloss I like and a blush I tolerate.
I won’t take my chances purchasing any more Memeboxes, but I might order specific products from their website since I’m still interested in trying Korean beauty products. I just won’t leave it up to Memebox to surprise me.
I’ve seen quite a few Meme Box openings on YouTube and they all seems to be pretty good… You’re right about your box though… doesn’t look that fun. 😛 BUT that lip color must be an “in” color this year. I got a similar shade in my Influenster #MKGlam Box. I thought I was going to hate the orange, but once I put it on, it didn’t look half bad. 🙂
Maybe I just got a dud:( Who knew orange could be such a fun color? It is fun to try new things.
I would stick to the skin care boxes from memebox, I don’t like the makeup products they include very much. I just got the lucky box #5 and love every one of the items in the box! You should definitely try the lucky boxes
Thanks for the advice! I might try a lucky box sometime.
Great review! Thanks for being so thorough haha. I think the lip color looks great and… wouldn’t mind getting your pore eraser 😛 My pores are such a huge issue for me! Do you have a review of Vain Pursuits? I’d love to read what you have to say… my girlfriends are all talking about it.
I have never heard of Vain Pursuits. Will have to check it out.